The Holy Gospel according to Matthew 28: 18-20
Now the eleven disciples went to Galilee, to the mountain to which Jesus had directed them. When they saw him, they worshiped him, but they doubted. And Jesus came and said to them, “All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me. Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit and teaching them to obey everything that I have commanded you. And remember, I am with you always, to the end of the age.”
—
A sermon for Fanwood Presbyterian Church in Fanwood, NJ. The final installment in their summer Broadway preaching series, delivered Sunday, August 30, 2026.
Good morning! I’m so grateful to be here with all of you today! Your Pastor is one of my dearest friends and I’m deeply thankful that y’all were amenable to lending her out today to my congregation on Long Island, St. Andrew’s Lutheran Church. We’ve been friends for more than 15 years. We first met where so many friendships begin: at an academic conference on funeral planning. We realized rather quickly that we had crossed paths years before - when she was a seminarian at Union Seminary and I was a recent NYU grad working in an art gallery in Queens.
My brother, Tommy, and I both attended the Tisch School of the Arts at NYU. He graduated two years after me in 2008 and the whole Button family came for the festivities. Buttons from across south Louisiana descended on Manhattan. I wanted us to experience things together that would bond us and what better than going as a family to a Broadway show. The hot ticket at the time was to the revival of “Sunday in the Park with George.” And because it was 2008 - I, at the tender age of 22, had been offered an extraordinary line of credit by American Express, so I bought tickets for the entire Button family.
It was an incredible production. With music and lyrics by Stephen Sondheim, the musical tells the story of George Seurat’s pointillist masterpiece, A Sunday Afternoon on the Island of La Grande Jatte. It is Seurat’s most famous artwork and is on permanent display at the Art Institute of Chicago (and has a stunning cameo in the 1986 classic Ferris Bueller’s Day Off). Seurat used tiny, distinct points of color, applied in patterns to form an image. This style, which came to be known as pointillism, relies on the viewer’s eye and mind to blend these tiny points of color into a fuller range of tones, bringing whole figures and landscapes into view.
The painting is enormous - I beg you, if you ever get the chance to visit it in Chicago, do it! It’s huge - more than l0 feet across and almost 7 feet tall - the subject matter is somehow both magisterial and mundane. A view of Parisians reclining, relaxing, and altogether enjoying themselves on the banks of the River Seine. Inspired by optical effects and perception, color theory and scientific research, Seurat used small, contrasting dots of oil paint - of almost uniform size to compose the painting which took more than two years to complete.
The 2008 revival, which I remind you I paid a small fortune that I was not in possession of to bring 10 Cajuns to, used 3D animations projected across the stage which moved in harmony with the music, vividly bringing the painting to life. George Seurat takes the stage and begins by speaking the refrain that repeats throughout the show:
White
A blank page or canvas
The challenge: bring order to the whole
Through design
Composition
Tension
Balance
Light
And harmony
As these words are spoken - words that compose a mental image - projections of thousands of points of light and color compose a rich visual image. It was breath-taking, Seurat’s work combines thousands of points of color bringing into relief a staggering masterpiece and the projections did the same, animating the process Seurat sings about as the artwork comes in and out of focus around him. I was utterly transported, it was one of those rare experiences where - as you are experiencing it, you know that it will stay with you. I was practically dizzy at intermission, I was so transported. As the whole Button family shuffled into the lobby, my grandfather and brother took me aside urgently and begged me to never make them see another Broadway show ever again.
Hey, the Buttons had an experience - just not the same one. What was an amazingly transcendent experience for me, was a stultifying one for the other Buttons. And I think we can all agree bad experiences are often more memorable than good ones!
As an artist and theologian, I am deeply interested in the many ways that tiny points of astounding beauty reveal swirling masterpieces. After all, God is an artist - bringing together mystery upon mystery, unveiling God’s love in a million ways in a million places. A great mystery of our faith is evoked in our Gospel reading today. Jesus commissions the disciples: sending them out into the world to spread the Good News and baptize in the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. It’s here that we hear one of the few instances, alongside Jesus’s own baptism, where this Trinitarian “formula” appears in the Gospels. A shared belief in the Trinity is just one of the things that binds Lutherans and Presbyterians together. Not that I’ve ever managed to explain it very well. But, when I do venture to try and explain it, I talk about color and light.
The more we grasp at the beautiful mysteries of our faith, the Trinity among them, the more we seek God’s love in all of its many expressions, the deeper we grow in relationship with God and one another. Color has a story and it’s the story of how we experience the world. And I think it has a lot to teach us about how we can better understand our faith. Since the beginning of time, artists and philosophers have argued about color, the animating light force behind what we can and can’t see. It was Sir Isaac Newton who first discovered that color is the shadow of what we can’t see. He did it playing with two prisms. First, he created a rainbow by pulling apart the wavelengths in light. That is something many had done before, but what Newton did next changed forever our understanding of not just light and color, but also the holy and sacred. With his other prism, he put the wavelengths of color back together again, creating one single beam of light. This likely doesn’t sound too terribly radical to us given that I’m basically describing the album art for Pink Floyd’s “Dark Side of the Moon,” but trust me when I tell you this was a really big deal in the 1660s.
For centuries to that point, people believed that the rainbows that come pouring out of prisms are the result of imperfections in the glass, not that color comes from light. Entire theologies were built around this understanding: “Pure white sunlight was considered a gift from God; it was unthinkable that it could be broken down or, worse still, created by mixing colored lights together.” (From The Secret Lives of Color.) Then, Newton proved that the colors that we see are merely reflections of the type of light they absorb. Take, for example, a juicy tomato. Its red skin soaks up all the short and medium wavelengths of light -- all the blue, purple, green, yellow and orange. The remaining wavelengths -- the reds! --hit our eyes and are processed in the brain. The colors that we perceive are, in actuality, precisely what they aren’t: the part of the light spectrum being reflected away.
Now, I’m guessing most of you can tell me what happens when you mix the colors red and yellow. You make orange, right. If you’re not familiar with what colors combined make what - I commend to you one of the many cast recordings of Sunday in the Park with George. But, in the world of color printing, three colors create a whole spectrum of color. You’ve maybe seen a color wheel, where every color in the rainbow is revealed in three overlapping circles. The colors of the three circles are cyan, magenta, and yellow. When they overlap they create the primary colors of red, green, and blue with black at the center.
Three colors coming together to create an entire rainbow is one way to explain the great mystery of our faith, our Triune God who is Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. The Holy Trinity reveals God in three persons and three ways that God works in our lives, but God contains multitudes and is not confined to any one of them. God is not limited by the Trinity; the Trinity is an expression of the manifold nature of God. In Matthew 28:19 Jesus instructs his disciples, “Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, and teaching them to obey everything that I have commanded you.” When we baptize people in the name of the Holy Trinity we claim them in their entirety, in the myriad ways that their identity finds expression.
As three overlapping colors create a whole spectrum, the Trinity reveals the multitude of God in each of us. The Holy Trinity is an expression of the many ways that God holds us in their heart and loves us without condition, loves every part of us, loves every color we come in, loves every language we speak, loves every part of us that makes us who we are. We are surrounded by a million points of light, reflecting and absorbing millions of shades of color - even in the darkest night, there are stars swirling above us. And we are surrounded by the love of God. Light hits our eyes and turns into an infinite combination of colors, of tones, of shades. Yet, we rarely stop to think about its mechanics, about how there are rods in our eyes that are reflecting back the colors that aren’t absorbed by an object. Instead, we bask in it. We revel in sunrises and sunsets. We gasp when we come upon deep blue seas and purple fields of lavender. We are humbled by it and in awe of it.
If there’s anything I’ve learned over the years it’s that, when it comes to the Trinity, you can definitely overthink it. Instead, we must bask and revel in it. Be humbled by it and overwhelmed at the wonders of all the ways that God’s love finds us. Every day, every hour, every minute, every second, we are surrounded by a million points of light, bringing into relief God’s masterpiece. A vast and enormous canvas populated by a swirling creation. The Trinity is for us. God is for us. The Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit are for us. For all time, “always, to the end of the age.” And it is revealed to us everyday in an always shifting, always being unveiled, always being made new, masterpiece composed of infinite points of light. Thanks be to God.
